Valedictorian’s speech about racism sparks discussion
SARANAC LAKE — There has been a flood of reaction, mostly positive, to the Saranac Lake High School valedictorian’s speech about anti-Asian racism she endured.
Francine “Frannie” Newman’s blunt speech came as a surprise to many. “Talking about race has never been something I’ve been comfortable with,” she said in her opening. But even if she had kept quiet about it until now, her half-Chinese heritage clearly was a dominant factor in how some classmates and teachers viewed her, and in the “self-loathing” she said she developed as a result.
The speech appeared as part of a commencement video that graduates and their families watched as a drive-in movie Friday night at Tucker Farms. It also was posted on the high school website, http://highschool.slcs.org (it begins around the 18:10-minute mark of the two-hour video) and on YouTube as “2020 SLHS Graduation Valedictory Address.”
It has also made the rounds on Facebook, where passionate comments have flowed freely.
But she had delivered the speech weeks before, in the first half of June when the SLHS seniors were recorded walking across a stage, receiving their diplomas and hugging their families.
“Hard message to hear”
The school district superintendent and high school principal were there when Newman and Salutatorian Rosemary Crowley gave their speeches for the camera. For these leaders, it was hard to hear Newman say all this racist bullying had taken place at their schools on their watch. She didn’t name names, but she said teachers in particular grades had made things worse for her. It put them on the spot, but they let the speech go.
“It was obvious from Francine’s opening statement that she had a message to share, it was going to be a hard message to hear, and it was going to require me to do some serious self-reflection,” Superintendent Diane Fox wrote in an email to the Enterprise.
“Over the last several years the district has worked to mitigate the socio-economic inequalities in our school district by educating staff, working with families and outside agencies, and embracing the Community School model. I take personal pride in the work we are doing.
“Then Francine stepped up to the microphone and called me out. She said, ‘What about me? What are you doing to mitigate the inequality I face as a member of a minority group in a small town in the North Country?’ She’s right. What am I doing?
“Rosemary’s speech — remembering that these graduates were labeled ‘the worst class ever’ — bolstered Francine’s main points: perspectives matter, words matter. Both spoke of wrongs done years ago that continue to shape their thoughts and feelings today.
“Like people all over the world, I, too, am reflecting on the society in which we live and what role I can play to make it a better place for everyone.”
High School Principal Josh Dann was also there for the taping of Newman’s speech. Not only was he the head of her high school; he had previously been principal of Petrova Elementary School when Newman said she suffered from racist name-calling and non-support by teachers.
“Initially, I was taken aback,” he said. “I think anytime you hear that kind of message, you think about what you could have done differently.”
After she delivered her speech, he said he told her “Good job” and apologized.
“Things happen under your watch, and hopefully it doesn’t happen again, but the next time when that thing arises, we can make better choices,” he said.
Hopefully, he said, Newman’s speech will embolden future students and their families to speak up about racism sooner after they experience it.
“I certainly had no idea that that’s how she felt, and I feel bad that that message wasn’t delivered at a time when I maybe could have helped her,” he said.
He said he’s glad her speech has started important conversations throughout the community.
“We can’t shy away from this,” he said. “We have to go at it. And we can always get better.”
Comments under the YouTube post were all supportive of Newman.
“As a graduate of SLHS and one of the few minority students there, I can relate to so many of these statements,” Ami Kirollos wrote. “I am so impressed by this young lady’s courage and so grateful for your efforts to educate. I’m optimistic to see the culture of SLHS a progress for the better, much because of your bravery.”
“Young lady, you have made me proud to be a graduate of Saranac Lake after so many years,” wrote 1967 SLHS graduate Bernie Branch.
“This is one of the best graduation speeches I’ve ever heard,” wrote BJ-Maggie Noreault. “Francine, if your truths and honest perception of life are an example of what we have to look forward to in the future, I feel positive our world will be ok.”
Comments were more numerous and more mixed, and debate more heated on the Enterprise Facebook page, where a Monday morning post linking to the newspaper’s story on the speech had drawn about 150 comments by 4 p.m. The vast majority supported Newman, but the first two comments, made minutes after the post went live, were attempts to shout down people who bring up racism.
“Stop already!!!” wrote Shawn Boyer of Saranac Lake.
“ENOUGH!!!!!!!” wrote Jason Pedu of Lake Placid.
Boyer and Pedu, regular Enterprise Facebook commenters who lean to the political right, continued to respond as dozens of people debated with them. Amid the curse words and abusive language on both sides of the argument, it came out that Boyer and Pedu had also been bullied in school.
“These days everyone is a bunch of (expletive)!” Pedu wrote. “I was 100 lbs and had a big nose. I got bullied but never cried like a little (expletive) about it. It’s life in the real world.”
“i was bullied my entire school years!” Boyer wrote. “No controlling the abuse. I took matters into my own hands. Lifted weights, grew stronger, and then started fighting back.”
“Shawn Boyer I’m sorry you were bullied as well,” Frannie’s mother Ara Newman responded. “It would be so wonderful if you could be a part of making future children’s experiences more pleasant than your own. No child should ever be bullied.”
Pedu and a couple of other commenters said the Saranac Lake schools where this racism happened should be shut down, or all their teachers and administrators fired. Others noted that it did not reflect well on Saranac Lake and its schools.
Most, however, praised Newman for her bravery.
“Thank you for teaching us Frannie,” wrote Raymond Dora, who was the senior teacher at Lake Clear School when she went there in kindergarten and first grade, and this month retired as principal of St. Bernard’s Catholic school. “Never give up. Congratulations and Godspeed.”