Judge rules tracks must stay

Railroad ‘ecstatic’; trail supporters call it a ‘real blow’; some expect appeal

The Adirondack Scenic Railroad makes its way along the tracks near Saranac Lake in October 2016. (Enterprise photo — Lou Reuter)

MALONE — A judge ruled Wednesday that the state’s plan to build a 34-mile rail trail was “arbitrary and capricious” and failed to follow numerous state laws.

“The 2016 UMP [unit management plan] is annulled and vacated, in its entirety, and in each and every part,” acting state Supreme Court Justice Judge Robert Main Jr. informed the state departments of Environmental Conservation and Transportation and the state Adirondack Park Agency.


The Adirondack Rail Preservation Society, which operates tourist trains under the Adirondack Scenic Railroad name, sued the state in April 2016. The lawsuit stemmed from a plan by the DEC and DOT, and approved by the APA, that would have removed 34 miles of train tracks between Lake Placid and Tupper Lake and replaced them with a multi-use trail. The plan also called for another multi-million-dollar state investment to rehabilitate 45 miles of railroad tracks from Tupper Lake to Big Moose, allowing passenger trains to operate between Tupper Lake and Utica.

The railroad in question runs 141 miles between Utica and Lake Placid, and the state owns the 119-mile majority between Remsen and Lake Placid. ASR, under lease from the state, has run tourist trains between Utica and the Old Forge area since the early 1990s, and from 2000 through 2016 also ran them also between Lake Placid and Saranac Lake.

Judge Robert Main Jr. (Photo provided)

After several years of public hearings, comment periods and review by state agencies, the APA approved the 2016 plan as an amendment for the Remsen-Lake Placid Travel Corridor UMP. The revised plan split the corridor into two segments, with Segment 1 running from Remsen to Tupper Lake and the trail making up Segment 2.

The DOT oversees travel corridors, such as roads, highways and train tracks, in the state, and the DEC generally takes care of trails and outdoor recreation, especially within the Adirondack Park. But to facilitate the construction of the trail, the DOT, under a memorandum of understanding, passed off management of Segment 2 to the DEC while still retaining ownership of the corridor.

The order

The judge found that removing railroad infrastructure to construct a trail would effectively remove Segment 2 from Remsen-Lake Placid Travel Corridor designation; therefore, such a use could not be allowed in a unit management plan for the travel corridor.

“The multi-recreational use trail would be just that, a recreational trail,” Judge Main wrote. “The SLMP [State Land Master Plan] expressly defines travel corridors in terms of either automobile or railroad transportation. … The Court rejects respondents’ self-serving conclusion that the 2016 UMP is consistent with the SLMP.”

The judge goes on for several pages, calling the plan “an impermissible circumvention of the APA Act” and saying the state’s rationale on this matter is “not based in reason.”

Another point of contention in the lawsuit was that the plan violates historic preservation laws since the travel corridor is on the state and national Registers of Historic Places. The state had argued in its planning process that it would honor the history of the line through a number of interpretive displays along the length of the trail. The state submitted a letter to the court saying it would work on a more comprehensive preservation plan.

But the judge tore that to pieces, calling it “irrational and nonsensical. … This lack of meaningfully addressing any mitigation or avoidance plan is fatal to the 2016 UMP.”

The third main obstacle to the state’s plan is that it doesn’t own all the land the corridor crosses.

During the early parts of the lawsuit, it came to light that the state did not own about a half-mile of the corridor through the North Country Community College campus in Saranac Lake. In the past few months, the state has worked with the college and the counties of Essex and Franklin, all of which jointly own the land, to purchase the parcel or gain access for the trail, with the DEC going so far as notifying the Saranac Lake village board of its plan to buy the land.

At the Lake Placid end of the line, the Lake Placid-North Elba Historical Society owns the last bit of tracks and the train depot. The state acknowledged this and said the trail would simply end at the property line.

However, the judge found this lack of title to the entire corridor to be another fatal blow.

“It is, thus, likewise undisputed that the 2016 UMP is based upon mistaken information, assumptions, and beliefs,” he wrote. “That such a reasonable and appropriate title review, which is basic and ordinary legal research, did not occur until after approval … is inexplicable.

“Whether the owners will enter some type of agreement, require the State of New York to exercise its eminent domain powers, or agree to some other alternative is the subject of conjecture not appropriate for this court.”

Main’s final order was that the APA, DEC and DOT develop and approve “a UMP that complies with the instant decision.” He also said these agencies “hereby are enjoined and restrained from implementing the 2016 UMP pending preparation and approval of a revised UMP that conforms with the instant decision, order and judgment.”

A DEC spokesman said the agency will put out a press release later Wednesday and declined to comment further.


The railroad’s public relations director, Mark Piersma, said the mood at its office was “ecstatic.” ARPS put out a press release shortly after news of the decision broke.

“ARPS believes that Judge Main has taken a balanced and objective approach,” the press release said. “It is unclear, at this time, whether NYS will appeal this ruling.

“For our organization this [legal] action has been a financial strain and has taken away resources from continuing to operate and expand a successful business. Efforts will be made to reach out to the communities served along the rail transportation corridor to begin to build packages which will highlight local offerings and provide for increased economic impact.”

ARPS was denied an operating permit for the northern end of the line this summer. Piersma said the railroad has made no decisions about its next steps, including whether it would seek damages from the state for its loss of operating revenue this summer.

On the other side of the debate, Adirondack Recreational Trail Advocates President Joe Mercurio said he was still grappling with the decision. ARTA is a local group formed in 2010 to push for replacing the state-owned tracks with a trail.

“Obviously I’m deeply disappointed,” said Mercurio, who lives in Saranac Lake. “If the judge’s decision is upheld, assuming this doesn’t go any further, then this will be a real blow and a loss to the Tri-Lakes community.

“I think my impression all along was that the state, [and] the DEC and APA in particular, had gone out of their way to address the issue in every possible way, so I frankly was a little surprised at the judge’s decision. I really was under the impression that the state had done a pretty decent job.”

“This just delays the inevitable,” North Elba town Supervisor Roby Politi said. “This is a lower-court decision that, regardless whether the decision was for or against, it was certain to be appealed anyway. It’s going to go to a higher court anyway.”

In Politi’s hometown of Lake Placid, the government and business leaders who speak up tend to favor a trail over the train.

“It’s unfortunate,” Politi added, “because the people of this community would like to be able to get on their bikes and go to Saranac Lake. I think it would be a popular use. I don’t think anybody wants the trains back — the minority do.

“It’s my belief that this decision is going to get overturned,” he continued. “That’s my feeling.”

Tupper Lakers have been split on the rail-trail debate, with some wanting passenger trains to return after a more-than-50-year absence — except for a brief run during and after the 1980 Winter Olympics — and others preferring to use the corridor for other types of transport, especially snowmobiling.

Adirondack Machines shop owner Darwin Benware said snowmobilers need at least a foot of snow to drive over the tracks without damaging their sleds. He said the rails deter other snowmobilers from traveling to Tupper Lake to escape areas congested with other riders, such as Old Forge.

“It would be nice if they were removed [the tracks] all the way to Old Forge,” Benware said. “That’s where most of my traffic comes from.

“Whenever they come up, it’s nuts,” he added. “The whole town is full of snowmobilers. All the restaurants are full. The gas station is full.”

Village Mayor Paul Maroun said passenger trains would be a good form of mass transport, connecting three major Adirondack villages to downstate and the rest of the country. He has also supported a trail beside the rails, which state agencies said would not be feasible.

“I know that in my heart I always thought the rail should keep operating because I think it’s a way of mass transportation into the heart of the Adirondacks,” Maroun said. “From being a naval officer, you don’t tear up a strategic type of transportation — in fact, in this area, one of the few strategic types of transportation into the heart of the Adirondacks.”

Staff Writers Antonio Olivero and Aaron Cerbone contributed to this report.


Today's breaking news and more in your inbox

I'm interested in (please check all that apply)
Are you a paying subscriber to the newspaper? *

Starting at $4.75/week.

Subscribe Today